One of the most common problems that mechanics and DIYers have to deal with every day is old rusted screws. If you’ve ever experienced such a problem yourself, you know it can be extremely frustrating. However, there is still a way out from this – screw extractor sets.
Screw extractor sets are one of the most helpful tools that professional handymen and DIYers can have. If you are in the market for such a tool, you are in the right place.
In this article, you will find the 10 best screw extractor sets that are present in the market. So, make sure to check them out, and hopefully, you’ll find something that fits your needs.
If you are in a hurry, check out our top picks:
Disclaimer – This article may contain affiliate links, this means that at no cost to you, we may receive a small commission for qualifying purchases.
IRWIN Tools 11119 Screw Extractor Set
- Comes with an excellent storage case
- Amazing price
- Works with broken fasteners
- Easy to use
IRWIN 3101010 Screw Extractor Set
- Unmatched build quality
- High-grade tools
- Extremely durable
COMOWARE Screw Extractor Set
- Extremely versatile
- Supreme grip
- Durable built quality
1. IRWIN Tools 11119 Screw Extractor Set
First up, we have the IRWIN Tools 11119 Screw Extractor Set. IRWIN is one of the leading brands in the market of tools. Hence, when you come across an IRWIN product, you know you’re putting your money in the right place.
Like most IRWIN screw extractor sets, this model also comes in a storage case. It includes ten pieces of extractors to remove different kinds of bolts, socket screws, fittings, and studs. Not only that, but it can remove different sizes of screws as well, including painted, rusted, broken, or jammed screws.
The drill bits feature spiral flutes, which aims at increasing grip as you continue the drilling process. This means it will eventually pull out even the most stubborn screws. Just make sure that you are working with the right size tool.
To make things easier for novices, the manufacturer has etched the sizes on each tool. Hence, it won’t be difficult for you to identify the right extractor.View Latest Price
- Great for removing broken fasteners
- Drill bits with spiral flutes for better grip
- Includes a storage case
- Reasonably priced
- Quality of storage case not up to the mark
2. COMOWARE Screw Extractor Set
The COMOWARE Screw Extractor Set comes with a budget-friendly price tag without compromising with quality. Hence, you get the best of both worlds – quality and affordability.
First off, let’s talk about its construction. The left-hand spiral drill uses HSS M2 steel material. This means this set of screw extractors have the upper hand in terms of durability, compared to other ordinary steel drills. They are also much harder and robust.
The set has a total of 10 pieces – five HSS M2 drill bits for the left hand and five screw extractors of varying sizes. The screw extractors are made of high-quality alloy steel. Thus, you can easily remove stubborn fasteners, including screws, bolts, and studs.
Another unique feature about this screw extractor set is its 118° angle. This allows you to easily cut into any workpiece with small axial resistance. Not only that, but it also improves heat dissipation, thereby enhancing its durability.View Latest Price
- Affordable and versatile
- Features 5 different sizes of screw extractors
- Features 5 left-hand drill bits
- Sturdy and Durable
- Provides increased grip
- Comes in a storage case
3. IRWIN 3101010 Screw Extractor Set
For our premium pick, we have the IRWIN 3101010 model. At a glance, you may think this is an overpriced product, but it is totally worth it! That’s because this set provides multiple tools for any kind of extraction job. Hence, you won’t ever have to buy another set for that purpose.
The set includes a whopping total of 48 extractors, including multi-spline extractors, spiral flute extractors, left-hand cobalt drill bits, and bolt extractors. The left-hand cobalt drill bits can be used to drill into the fastener itself without damaging the workpiece.
Additionally, the spiral flute extractors are low torque. Hence, it can easily loosen and remove just about fastener without any hassle.
Overall, the IRWIN 3101010 Screw Extractor Set is an excellent all-in-one product for both home and professional use.View Latest Price
- Professional-grade tools
- Provides multiple tools
4. Alden 8440P Grabit Pro Damaged Screw Extractor
If the above-reviewed products didn’t work for you in terms of affordability, the Alden 8440P Grabit Pro Damaged Screw Extractor Set might tick all the boxes for you. At an affordable price, this set of screw extractors comes with a single purpose – to remove four-inch screws (both square and hexagonal drives).
The extractors are made of high-quality HSS M2 steel. Hence, you don’t have to worry about its durability. Other than removing screws, this set can also remove 3/8-inch bolts.
The four tools also feature different widths that allow you to work on different bolt and screw sizes. This industrial-strength screw extractor set is compatible with any standard reversible drill and a ¼ inch hex screwdriver. You can use it to extract multiple types of fasteners from popular brands, including Phillips, Hex, Fearson, Trox, Tri-Wing, and almost any tamper resistant screws.View Latest Price
- Made of high-quality HSS M2 premium steel
- Compatible with a 3/8-inch drill and ¼-inch hex screwdriver
- Used for removing almost any tamper-resistant screws
- Easy to use
- Limited use
5. Alden 4507P Grabit Micro Screw Extractor Kit
Next up, we have another screw extractor set from Alden, 4507P Grabit Micro Screw Extractor Kit. This product is ideal for those handymen who work with small stripped screws, usually the ones found in most electronic appliances.
The Alden 4507P comes with four screw removers in different sizes. With these tools, you can remove any kinds of screws ranging from sizes 3mm up to 6mm.
The tools feature a two-step drill bit on one side and an extractor on another. The bits are also reversible and suitable with a 1/8-inch drill chuck.View Latest Price
- Made of high-speed steel M2 material
- Reasonable price
- Sturdy and durable
- Best for removing small sized screws
- Not suitable for heavy-duty or large screws
6. NEIKO 01925A Screw Extractor Set
The NEIKO 01925A Screw Extractor Set is another low-cost solution for all your screw extraction needs. The package includes five drill bits, and five allow extractors of varying sizes. Hence, using this, you can get a lot of work done at home or at the workshop.
The extractors that come in this set are to be used with a drill. Thus, if the extractors are not strong enough, it will break in no time during the fast drilling process. But with the NEIKO 01925A Screw Extractor Set, you don’t have to worry about that! Thanks to its cobalt alloyed steel construction. No matter the pressure and speed, you can expect the NEIKO tools to perform exceptionally well and get the screws extracted with ease.
The extractors also feature spiral flutes, which means it will burrow deeper into the screw. This makes the extraction process all the more easy and hassle-free!View Latest Price
- Cobalt steel construction for increased strength
- Sturdy and durable
- Comes in a solid metal case
- Provides ten extraction tools
- Affordable price
- Not very easy to work on a stripped screw
7. OCGIG 11 PCS Damaged Broken Screw Extractor Set
Next up, we have the amazing 11-piece Screw Extractor Set from OCGIG. For those of you looking for a set of extractors to work on broken or damaged fasteners, this product is for you!
Though it is specially designed to remove screws, you can use it for removing studs and bolts too. The 11-piece set includes five-screw extractors and five drill bits. The extractors differ in sizes from 1/8-inch up to ¾-inch. The whole package also comes with a tap holder.
All the tools from this set are made from chrome vanadium steel. Hence, they can tackle even the most difficult fasteners as they are exceptionally sturdy and highly durable.View Latest Price
- Includes a versatile range of screw extractors
- Includes five drill bits
- Suitable for removing multiple fastener sizes and types
- Spiral-styled extractors provide increased grip.
- Some customers had complaints regarding the tap holder.
8. IRWIN 53535 Screw Extractor Set
Here is another set of screw extractors from IRWIN. The IRWIN 53535 Screw Extractor kit includes five different kinds of screw extracting tools. Note that this set is especially used for extracting screws from softer materials like pipes and fittings or thin workpieces.
The best thing about this model is that it offers extractors for removing both left-hand and right-hand threaded screws. This is something you can’t find in most similar products.
From broken studs to fittings to socket screws, you can easily get through the extraction process with this product. The left-hand spiral drill bits also provide extra grip during the drilling process.View Latest Price
- Great for removing screws from softer materials
- Offers five different kinds of screw extractors
- Features spiral flutes
- Great grip
- Not suitable to work on hard materials
9. Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set
The Elitexion Screw Extractor Remover Set is an ideal pick for professionals as they are more suitable for heavy-duty applications. The entire set offers a total of six extraction tools ranging from 1/8-inch up to ¾-inch.
If you want to tackle broken and stubborn fasteners, this model is the go-to! Each of these tools is extra-sturdy and hard as they are made from high-quality steel. Not only that, but they are further heat-treated to bear maximum pressure.
You can use this set of tools for extracting broken screws, studs, pipes, and even bolts. Another strong selling point is their affordability at around $10 only.View Latest Price
- Extremely strong as they are heat-treated
- Suitable for hard materials
- Professional-grade tool
- Comes in a plastic storage case
- Provides a wide range of extractor sizes
- Plastic storage case may break easily.
10. Moody Tools 58-0670 Screw Extractor Set
The Moody Tools 58-0670 Screw Extractor Set is a unique one. We understand that not everyone needs a heavy-duty screw remover. Or maybe, sometimes, you may just need a little force with some broken or stripped screws. When that situation arises, you can depend on the Moody Tools 58-0670 Screw Extractor Set.
The unique feature about this set is that it is a manual hand-use tool and doesn’t require the use of a drill. No doubt, your hands will not work as fast as a drill. But this set can help you remove some small screws around the house.
The set includes a total of six extractors. It features durable aluminum handles and a knurled grip for better control. Also, the hex swivel top reduces hand fatigue and adds more to your overall convenience.View Latest Price
- Very affordable
- Great grip
- Aims at reducing hand fatigue
- Works best with small screws
- Not suitable for large or stubborn screws
Screw Extractor Sets Buyer’s Guide:
The features and construction of screw extractions differ a lot from one product to another, which is why it is important to know exactly what to look for. If you are not familiar with screw extractors, here is a short buying guide to help you before you make your purchase.
As with any other tool, you should always check if the screw extractor set has good quality. With tools like screw extractors, quality is extremely important. If the quality is not good enough, the pieces in the set will barely last over a year. But if it is of good quality, you can expect it to easily last more than a decade.
Ease of Use:
Before you buy a particular screw extractor set, always make sure that the set is easy to use. Screw extractors should make your work easy and not harder. If you can’t use it with ease, it’s better to look for another set.
Another important thing to consider before you buy a screw extractor set is the sizes included. Most screw extractor sets can handle just about any work that you come across. While on the other hand, some sets can only perform a certain amount of job due to their limited sizes. Make sure the set you want to buy comes with the maximum number of common screw sizes.
Now that you know the top 10 best screw extractor sets and what to look for, it is now up to you to decide on what you want to get. Consider each and every option thoroughly and choose the one which you think is best.